Plenty of prospective donors will skim past a year-end email from an organization they don’t know. Far fewer ignore a call from a friend, client, or colleague who sits on that organization’s board. That trust is one of the most valuable assets your nonprofit has in December, and with a bit of preparation, your board can put it to work.
Think of board members as connectors first and askers second. Their greatest value is the credibility they bring to a first conversation: they know the organization from the inside, they’ve committed their own time, and they can reach business and philanthropic circles your development staff may never touch. Staff can then handle the details, the paperwork, and the follow-through.
A confident conversation starts with a short set of talking points. Consider giving each board member a single page that covers:
This year, board members also have a useful new point to share with donors who take the standard deduction. Beginning in 2026, non-itemizers may deduct up to $1,000 in qualifying cash gifts to certain qualified charities, or $2,000 for married couples filing jointly. Gifts to donor-advised funds or supporting organizations don’t count toward this deduction. The IRS covers the specifics in its guidance on charitable deductions for non-itemizers. Board members can mention it as general information and suggest donors confirm the details with their own tax advisor.
The best fundraising conversations sound more like discovery than a pitch. Board members who ask what a prospect cares about, and listen to the answer, can connect the donor interests they hear to a specific part of your work.
Format matters less than fit. Some prospects prefer to meet face-to-face, while others would rather keep it to a 15-minute phone or video call. Let the donor choose.
Personal experience often persuades better than statistics. A board member who explains why they joined the board, or what they’ve seen your programs accomplish, gives the donor a reason to care. Stories about the people you serve should be shared only with permission and never at the expense of anyone’s privacy.
Enthusiasm can get ahead of the rules, especially when a business wants something in return. Encourage board members to bring any offer of recognition, perks, or promotion back to staff before agreeing to terms.
Corporate sponsorships are a common example. If a local company offers to underwrite your holiday event, a simple thank-you with its name and logo may be treated very differently from promoting the company’s products. The IRS has identified the challenge of separating qualified sponsorship payments and related donor acknowledgments from advertising sales, which can be taxed as unrelated business income. Its overview of advertising versus qualified sponsorship payments explains where that line falls.
Donors who receive something of value, such as event tickets, raise a separate disclosure issue. Charities must provide a written disclosure statement to any donor making a quid pro quo contribution of more than $75. IRS Publication 1771 outlines what acknowledgments for cash and noncash gifts should include.
The year-end gift is the opening chapter. A prompt, personal thank-you from the board member who made the introduction, followed by an update on what the gift accomplished, shows donors their support mattered. Invite them into your 2027 plans early, and next December’s conversation will be a lot easier to start.
Fundraising goals land best when they’re grounded in a clear financial picture. GBQ’s nonprofit accounting team helps organizations assess funding needs, connect fundraising targets to their budgets, and review sponsorship and event arrangements before they create tax questions. Empowering growth is only a conversation away. Talk to an expert on our team.
Not necessarily. A sponsorship that only acknowledges the sponsor’s name or logo may be treated differently than one that promotes its products, which can create unrelated business income for the nonprofit.
Yes, within limits. Non-itemizers may deduct up to $1,000 in qualifying cash gifts ($2,000 for joint filers). Gifts to donor-advised funds and supporting organizations don’t qualify.